I think it would be a great simple addition to see springs added to the product list. While rubber bands are good and all, they can snap and are not good for every kind of stored energy application.
My idea:
offer a VEX Spring pack
maybe a 1" spring, 2" spring, 4" spring, and even 8" spring
I think this would be a simple addition to the product line yet greatly helpful to teams/design/etc.
are you thinking like an exposed spring, or one within something similar to a shock absorber housing, because something can push with force instead of pull would be useful.
As far as i know there are springs in the claw and in the clutches. There are also ways to twist rope to make a spring as well just like ancient catapults used.
Just to firmly drive home the point a few other folks have made. The Vex product line includes two stand-alone “legal” springs. No disassembly required.
One is called “Latex Tubing” the other is called “Rubber Band”.
This is one of those times when common use of a word (i.e. “spring”) is at odds with the proper use of the term in physics/engineering/math. Future techies should decide to start thinking of the Latex Tubing and Rubber Bands as springs; and to start training themselves to see compression and tension as two sides of a coin or two ends of a continuum, not as separate situations always needing separate tools/mechanisms
Also, even though it isn’t always immediately obvious how you can use tension to expand (pull?) a compressed mechanism back into it original (expanded) shape; or how to use them to resist compression forces; it is usually possible.
Like I said, anything other than rubber bands (latex tubing included). The difference between using a rubber band (or latex tubing) and a spring is the amount of give each object has when pushed/pulled in one direction.
You can “fold” the rubber band so it has less length and more force to get a “stronger spring”.
I can’t think of a reason why you’d need springs other than rubber bands. My team rarely uses latex tubing because it’s expensive (compared to rubber bands) and tends to break easily when it rubs over anything, or is just stretched a lot. The only advantage that I’ve found with latex tubing is that the spring constant decreases as you stretch it (its force is more constant than an ideal spring).
If you really want a powerful compression “spring” you can use pneumatics.
I never knew that the clutches had springs in them. I will have to take a look at that sometime soon…
And yes, I believe pneumatics could be used. Wouldnt a rubber link work as well? And depending on the application, the rubber outside of a wheel makes a nice cushion.