Descorer - Is it worth the extra motor?

Well we hit full court shots, but not with an adjustable hood. We just had varying speeds on our flywheel and made our own PID.

Good point. I was considering removing the adjustable hood and just change the velocity. But that leads to another question: should I use that motor for an indexer or a cap scraper/descorer or lift/descorer?

I’ll explain what we did, though it may or may not work for you guys:
1 motor roller intake
1 motor indexer
2 motor flywheel
4 motor drive

In the end it’s your choice, see what works best for you guys.

Changing a double shot by taking off a hood this close to worlds sounds like a really bad idea. If you want to attempt a 1 motor flywheel, you can try what 240P did on their High Quality robot. They used rubber links on their hood to help compress the ball more, thus making the shot feel harder opposed to not having it.

I would say if you’d a dedicated flag robot, then you’ll be in the front of the field hitting flags so it wouldn’t be worth your time to occasionally go back and de score a cab for it to only be put back up

Yup we were a cap bot at states since we weren’t able to fix our catapult. Most teams would descore but we just put the cap back up.

I would recommend using that motor for a small 4 bar to lift caps.

Yes. I have seen quite a few in AZ.

So, a single shot puncher good for auton only or a descoring arm? Which would be most effective?

I would think a descoring arm would be better, but surely you can come up with a ratchet system to use one motor for both intake and punching.
(But, this close to Worlds, don’t change what you have working.)

A single use puncher vs. describing arm confuses me in concept. If you don’t have a system to shoot, you surely have a cap placement system. (Especially if you’re going to Worlds)
If that cap system can’t descore in some way shape or form, then it’s probably not a great cap system. (Just saying)
By that logic, this said robot can already descore caps, but not shoot, leading me to believe that a single use puncher with one extra motor would be worthwhile, especially if you can come up with a ratchet system to use one motor for both intake and shooting.

I currently have a passive puncher on my robot

The robot can place. Single shooter is currently in use. Late to be modifying too much. Can’t have bothe descorer and shooter at this point. That’s why I was asking for feedback. Thanks for replying!

We have a motor that we are able to swap between the indexer and the descorer. This works well but we are cortex based so motors aren’t as important.