Nylon and Aluminum Screws now Illegal

I don’t think you understand my point. It’s not that the forums is a good representation of the general vex population or that a large percent of people use nylon screws… it’s that a large percentage of more serious vex teams use them.

I understand your point, and I agree that these should not be illegal. I just think it’s a pretty small point to take issue with. I’ll have to restrict our nylon and aluminum to our VEX-U team until something changes.

It’s not this issue in isolation, it’s this and all the other random arbitrary decisions that together are making the program worse.

Is it a huge deal to have to replace your colored pneumatic tubing with the official color? No
Is it a huge deal those old parts no longer on the website are illegal? No
Is it a huge deal you can’t use aluminum screws? No
Is it a huge deal robosource screws are technically illegal? No
Is it a huge deal you can’t buy from distributors any more and have to pay VEX’s high shipping costs? No

But it’s just this endless series of small annoying decisions that are slowly making everything subtly worse for no real discernable reason

As a student/mentor:
I think there is value in teaching students that even small optimizations, when done in large quantities, can make a difference. I also think that this change is just plain unnecessary and wasteful as there hasn’t been any significant issue with teams abusing lighter screws, and the GDC has explicitly rules them as legal in the past.

As an Head referee/Inspector:
I have no idea how the GDC wants us to enforce this rule. Inspection is complicated enough as it is, now they want me to test each screw on a robot to ensure it is made of (potentially non magnetic) stainless steel instead of aluminum?

So to answer your question: I know at least I care.

Also, and I hope this doesn’t come across as overly attacking any one person, there’s this common refrain that “this only affects high level teams, most teams don’t care” about certain decisions

High level teams are, in my experience, vital to the program. They’re the ones helping and inspiring newer teams. They’re the ones who stay on with the program as volunteers after graduating so it can continue to function. They’re the ones who provide cool robots that show sponsors and decision makers what this program can be like.

So I think they deserve more attention than their relatively small numbers would justify. Because you want them to continue to provide more value than their relatively small numbers would indicate they would.

For some people, some of these such as not being able to buy from resellers IS a big deal, not many teams have the funds to be able to afford VEX’s high shipping costs, and I am aware that shipping cost money does not go to vex, but many of these changes make it seem like they are just hungry for more money, and I doubt they actually care about competitors.

I think some people (including my self) see the VEX forum as representing the VEX community when in reality lots of VEX teams don’t participate in the forum or know that it exits.

you’re probably right about the majority of competitors not even thinking about this issue, but the main thing that gets me here is that I have yet to see a single person actively support this decision. it didn’t harm teams before and this decision only brings negative consequences

I never thought I’d see the day when people are saying VEX is affordable

/s…

…?

Or FTC where you have a 160 team World Championship because you can’t outshine FRC

Official star nylon screws from vex would sound nice, but I don’t know how sturdy those could be. I have a feeling that they might also start selling their own nylon screw (not thumbscrew) of some sort in the future.

GDC: Anything not sold in VEX Competition Mega Super Kit is vrc illegal.

School board members, who despise students not wearing board approved uniforms, and think that the olny book appropriate for PTLW class is an 1897 edition of the Mechanical Engineering Bible: :clap: :clap: :clap:

Illyana:

So this is how liberty dies...

20 char.

Pre-requisite - see my post in the shoulder screw thread for some additional rambling about the concept of “additional functionality”.

There are two reasons why, and they are both stated in Xenon’s original post (as well as pointed out by many others).

1 - As a competitor, if I have the option between an unclear ruling that sometimes goes my way, or a clear ruling that I don’t like, I will almost always choose the latter. We can go back to vague and indeterminate responses if you want…

2 - Hopefully, it is obvious that “all top teams do this” and “this provides no additional functionality” cannot both be true.

Debating the merit of one screw material over another is kind of missing the root point.
I would venture to guess that someone who is upset by this ruling is probably also in favor of allowing 3D printed parts to be legal.

If you were to make this assumption about me you would find yourself sorely mistaken.

And aside from the merits of different kinds of screws, I find it significantly problematic when something that was previously legal becomes illegal. If you’re trying to make the “accessibility” argument, many teams already own buckets full of old screws and other such fully functional parts that are now completely worthless. I’m happy to debate opening up new things for use in VRC, but I find making components that were perfectly allowed illegal to be counterproductive, harmful to the community, and frankly quite silly.

I can’t believe the impudence of someone on the GDC talking this way. You are not speaking only to students but also to mentors and coaches, many who may have significant investments in these types of fasteners.

I appreciate you taking the time to read and respond to the complaints made about this recent manual update, but I’m afraid that my point seems to have been entirely missed.

I get that the commodity hardware rule is intended to be very limiting in nature. You imply that the gdc is tightening up, so to speak, on the wording of this rule that allow teams to take advantage. But why has the gdc determined that teams using things such as nylon and aluminum screws a problem that needs to be fixed? And why has it been at least 5 years since nylon screws became a commonly used part (I can recall them being used in itz, but they certainly may have been used even before that) for the gdc to determine that the “fix” for this “problem” was to impose limits on parts that were not formerly there?

You agree and understand that nylon screws have been a widely used and well established component on robots for many years. Did you consider the negative consequences banning them would have on the program?

Banning them hurts all the organizations who have invested in these screws, and have amassed a large quantity of them. These organizations have spend money on these products, under the assumption that parts that were fully legal and fully available one year would not suddenly be completely banned the next. It is harmful to a program to have this sort of instability when it comes to purchased parts. It is also extremely wasteful to ban perfectly good parts that were in perfectly good use.

It also hurts the ability of teams and individuals to make design decisions and experiment with material properties, a huge part of engineering. When I first saw teams using nylon screws and asked them about it, it really opened me up to the prospect of high-level optimizations. This gave me encouragement to look into the material properties of different screws and nuts, and optimize my robots accordingly, and I believe I gained a lot from that experience, and I would wager that many other people here could tell you a similar story.

It also hurts excellent and amazing third party vendors, namely Robosource, which had taken the freedoms given by commodity hardware rules and third party material rules to create an incredibly useful source for parts which are almost always better and cheaper than vex products. But now, all of the nylon and aluminum screws Robosource sells are now illegal for competition use. Next I expect the nylon and aluminum nuts to be banned. And then the alternative material and alternative size spacers and washers. Where does it stop, and where does that leave places like Robosource which I hold as a crucial part of the program?

Can you deny that these harmful effects are true?

Can you give a positive effect that this change might have on the program?
(no, stronger rule clarity does not count. I’m sorry, but no credit given for solving a problem that the gdc created with a solution worse than the problem)

you say that

and I agree, but our points do not seem to align.

My root point is that this change is bad for the vrc program. What is yours?

I want to start by saying I appreciate that you’re engaging the community here on this. And I definitely see why it made more sense to put a hard cutoff rather than continue to give those vague answers that didn’t really answer anything.

I’m going to operate under the assumption that it would be seen as an acceptable outcome that aluminum and nylon screws, when actually being used as screws, would continue to be permissible. I’m also going to assume that the vast majority of nonstandard screws were aluminum/nylon, somebody please correct me if there’s some other material I’d forgotten.

Given both of those, is there a reason nylon and aluminum (or at minimum just aluminum, I get that nylon might get into gray areas) were not also permissible?

Also, I’m in favor of legal 3D printing but understand it would create more potential issues than it’s probably worth, so I’m not like… super pro 3D printing or anything. I just don’t want teams to have to throw out a bunch of stuff and buy new stuff, or to have to tell a team they failed inspection because of screws that were legal last season and aren’t this season.