I have been in plenty of matches where the Refs either didn’t see a possible DQ situation. They have cameras at every match to project the match on the screen, so why can’t they review a match with that situation. It only will take a minute to skip to that part of the match and see if the offending team should be DQed. I would like to hear your thoughts on this.
The logistics of this would be a nightmare for event partners.
4 Likes
read rule T1 in the game manual. Competitions run at a fast, smooth and any disruption can cause schedules to get messed up. The ref should see it without cameras and the head ref will make the decision. The head referee will make all these decisions and you can’t go against it. its final. In my opinion if the match is over and the referee makes the decision. its final. nobody is perfect but the referees will usually find the issue in the match and not need the video. IF it is tournament match then you should talk to the refs mid or after match right when it ends before they reset. If this wasn’t a rule. then 2 hour comps will be double the times. It will be terrible and the event members will have a tough time keeping schedule. So in conclusion. Keep it the way it is so the even runs fast and smooth.
Thank you for coming to my TED talk.
Butters
5 Likes
There was a nearly identical thread created only 17 days ago.
Before that, the topic was extensively discussed here, here, and here.
Do we really need another thread about video replay?
20 Likes
Merge this one thread or lock it.
1 Like